The Lie of Sustainable Seafood

Essential reading for everyone who eats fish—a long and superb article from Erik Vance arguing for something I’ve long suspected: that much so-called “sustainable seafood” really isn’t.

In the end, despite our best intentions, much of what we’re told or assume about the provenance of the seafood we eat is essentially a fish story.

Here is one fish story regarding Kenny Belov, one of the few fish wholesalers passionate about sustainability:

Belov knows firsthand what it means to trust the wrong guy. One of the more popular dishes at [his restaurant] was ahi tuna poke. Belov bought the fish from a dealer in the Marshall Islands who was the height of green cachet, claiming he was trolling a line behind his boat and pulling the fish out one at a time. Excited to promote good actors in the South Pacific, Belov planned a trip to visit the supplier. Over the phone, a befuddled employee at first welcomed the idea but then seemed hesitant.
“ ‘I’ve got to go fishing with you. That’s the rule,’ ” Belov told him. “Well, when the plane ticket was about to be bought, the fisherman confessed, ‘I’ve been lying to you.’ ”

I’ve long said that one of the best reasons to go vegan is that it’s so difficult and expensive to reliably source high-welfare animal products, that’s it’s easier to just not deal with the matter and instead cut those foods from your diet. Vance’s article makes clear that there’s a similar situation regarding sustainable seafood. Yeah, you can get it, but it’s such a hassle and the industry’s so fraught with incompetence and deceit that it’s easiest to simply make other food choices. It’s a shame Vance doesn’t even raise this as an option.

Still, an altogether outstanding article: share it with the seafood eaters in your life. (Via Boing Boing.) Link.

Newsletter Signup

Our newsletter is sent out irregularly and infrequently, because we only want to hit your inbox when we’ve got something compelling to share.